More Guys. Chat with x Hamster Live guys now!
You should both sit down and have a serious conversation about what you want and what she wants and if you can both deal with the compromise.
It's not that she doesn't believe you right now, but it is a bone she will never drop. In her mind if you never accept the gospel you are denying her eternal exaltation as a God.
They may need much more than casual contact with the church to see the truth in it. My wife and her family are a good example of this.